In the realm of computer security, the concepts of Ring 0 and Ring 1 are crucial to understanding the architecture of modern operating systems and the importance of maintaining a secure and stable environment. These concepts are especially relevant when discussing the functionality of firewalls and the integration of additional services like VPNs and SD-WAN.
Understanding Ring 0 and Ring 1
Modern processors use a hierarchical system known as "rings" to enforce different levels of privilege and protection for executing code. These rings range from Ring 0 to Ring 3, with Ring 0 being the most privileged and Ring 3 the least.
Ring 0: Also known as "kernel mode" or "supervisor mode," Ring 0 has unrestricted access to all system resources, including hardware, memory, and I/O operations. Code running in Ring 0 can execute any CPU instruction and reference any memory address. This level of access is necessary for the operating system kernel and critical drivers.
Ring 1: This ring is less privileged than Ring 0 and is typically used for device drivers that do not require full access to the system's resources. Code running in Ring 1 has more restricted access to hardware and memory, providing an additional layer of protection and stability.
Why Functions Should Avoid Ring 0
Security Risks: Allowing non-critical functions to run in Ring 0 significantly increases the attack surface of the system. If a vulnerability is exploited in Ring 0, the attacker gains full control over the system, potentially compromising all data and operations.
Stability Concerns: Ring 0 has direct access to all hardware and system memory. Any error or bug in code running at this level can lead to system crashes, data corruption, or other catastrophic failures.
Complexity and Maintenance: Managing and debugging code that runs in Ring 0 is more complex due to its high level of privilege and access. This complexity can lead to increased development and maintenance costs.
Segmentation in Firewalls: The Need for Separation
When it comes to firewalls, the principle of least privilege should guide the design and integration of additional functionalities such as VPNs and SD-WAN. These services should not operate in Ring 0, as doing so introduces unnecessary risks and complexities.
VPNs and Ring 0: VPN services handle encryption and decryption of network traffic. If these services run in Ring 0, any vulnerabilities or misconfigurations could expose the system to severe risks, allowing attackers to intercept or manipulate sensitive data.
SD-WAN and Ring 0: SD-WAN solutions manage network traffic dynamically, often optimizing routes and ensuring reliable connections. Running SD-WAN in Ring 0 can jeopardize the stability and security of the firewall, as any failure in the SD-WAN code can impact the entire system.
The Case for Ring 1
Reduced Privileges: By running VPNs and SD-WAN services in Ring 1, their access to system resources is restricted. This limits the potential damage an attacker can do if they exploit a vulnerability in these services.
Isolation and Stability: Segregating these functions from the firewall's core operations in Ring 0 enhances overall system stability. Errors in Ring 1 are less likely to cause catastrophic failures compared to those in Ring 0.
Focused Security: By keeping critical firewall operations in Ring 0 and moving auxiliary functions to Ring 1, security measures can be more effectively tailored and implemented. This segmentation allows for more precise monitoring and management of each component.
The Importance of Segmentation Between Ring 0 & Ring 1: Lessons from Clownstrike
Last Friday marked a significant event in the world of IT security, highlighting the critical importance of maintaining a clear segmentation between Ring 0 and Ring 1 operations. The Crowdstrike incident, which has since been dubbed "Clownstrike," led to the largest IT outage in history. This incident underscores why functions with critical security implications should not operate in Ring 0, where they have the highest level of system privilege.
Ring 2: The Ultimate & Recommended Segmentation
Functions such as VPNs and SD-WAN should actually not operate in ring 0 or ring 1. Instead, they should be preferably allocated to ring 2, where they can perform their tasks without having unrestricted access to the entire system. This segregation reduces the risk of a single vulnerability compromising the entire system.
Ring 2 is separate dedicated hardware or protected virtualization which is separate to the other network functions
Firewalls should maintain their core security functions in ring 0, but additional functionalities like VPNs should be moved to ring 2. This separation ensures that any vulnerabilities in the VPN software do not directly impact the firewall’s critical security operations. Ironically, the VPN function is the most unsafe functions shipped in Silicon Valley firewalls.
Dedicated Hardware for SD-WAN: To achieve the highest level of security and stability, SD-WAN functionalities should be entirely separated from the firewall. By operating SD-WAN on dedicated hardware (ring 2), independent from the firewall, you create an additional layer of security. This separation ensures that even if the SD-WAN is compromised, the firewall remains unaffected, preserving the integrity and security of the network.
Improved Stability and Performance: Isolating SD-WAN on separate hardware prevents it from consuming resources or introducing instabilities into the firewall’s operation. This approach optimizes performance for both the firewall and SD-WAN, ensuring reliable and efficient network operations.
Enhanced Security Posture: With SD-WAN operating on a separate stack, the attack surface is significantly reduced. Potential attackers must breach multiple layers of security, each with its own set of protections and restrictions, making it much harder to compromise the entire system.
Wrap
Incorporating additional functionalities like VPNs and SD-WAN into firewalls is essential for modern network security, but these services must be integrated thoughtfully. Ensuring that such functions do not run in Ring 0 is crucial to maintaining the security and stability of the system. By adhering to the principle of least privilege and properly segmenting these services, organizations can reduce risks, enhance protection, and build a more resilient cybersecurity infrastructure.
Ronald Bartels ensures that Internet inhabiting things are connected reliably online at Fusion Broadband South Africa - the leading specialized SD-WAN provider in South Africa. Learn more about the best SD-WAN provider in the world! 👉 Contact Fusion
